This question has resurfaced amid Israel’s military operations in Gaza and ongoing tensions with UN institutions. In theory, it is possible for the UN to suspend a member state, but in practice, it is a very challenging and complex process. For this to happen, there needs to be a legal basis, which is outlined in Articles 5 and 6 of the UN Charter, allowing for the suspension or expulsion of a member state.
A member state can be suspended if it is determined to have “persistently violated” the principles set out in the UN Charter. For a suspension decision, the recommendation of the Security Council and the approval of the General Assembly are required.
The United States’ veto power in the Security Council essentially blocks any attempt at sanctions against Israel before they even begin. As the prominent thinker Noam Chomsky once said, “The UN is a tool of the US.” However, as in the case of South Africa, a country could be isolated solely by the General Assembly’s decision to limit its participation.
While it is legally possible for the UN to suspend Israel, political and practical obstacles make it highly unlikely to happen.
The question lingering on the lips of the oppressed victims in Gaza is: “Where is the UN?” Since the beginning of Israel’s blockade on Gaza, this question has persisted. As the death toll rises and conflicts spread, the UN’s foundational purpose of “saving humanity from the scourge of war” seems like a distant mirage.
Tensions between Israel and the UN have been high for years and have now reached a breaking point. At the root of this tension lies the UN’s designation of Israel’s presence on Palestinian lands as an “occupation.” The recent conflicts in Gaza have further strained this fragile relationship.
A significant portion of the international community believes that Israel’s operations in Gaza violate UN resolutions, international agreements, and even the genocide convention. Some UN officials have accused not only Israel but also certain Palestinian groups of committing war crimes. In this period, Israel has come into direct conflict with UN institutions. The deaths of approximately 230 UN personnel during clashes and claims that Israel intentionally targeted UN peacekeeping troops in Lebanon underscore the severity of the situation.
This tension reached a peak on October 28 when Israel’s Knesset passed a decision to ban the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) from operating within Israeli borders, sparking widespread condemnation on the international stage.
UN Secretary-General António Guterres has repeatedly condemned Israel, leading to a ban on his entry into the country and the dismissal of his calls. This has become a clear indication of the UN’s impotence. As former US President Donald Trump once described it, the UN is a “club of people who talk a lot but do nothing,” and it has failed in its attempts to impose sanctions on Israel.
The famous quote from former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan has regained relevance today. While acknowledging the UN’s imperfections, he emphasized its indispensability – a sentiment that serves as a litmus test in today’s context.
Could the 1974 example of South Africa’s expulsion from the UN General Assembly be a precedent for Israel? Former Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir’s ironic remark, “I am not afraid of the UN condemning Israel, but rather of it praising Israel,” takes on new significance today.
The UN’s ineffectiveness in the Israel-Palestine conflict is a clear indication of the international order’s crumbling foundations. Recent developments reveal the deep impasse of global governance mechanisms.
Just as Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev famously banged his shoe on the desk in protest at the UN General Assembly in the 1960s, today’s global public also seeks a courageous figure to raise a voice against the UN’s silence. This symbolic act drew international attention in its time, and today, a similar response is needed.
Recalling Albert Einstein’s famous words: “I do not know with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones.”
This foresight is a warning of the devastating consequences humanity could face if current conflicts spiral out of control.
Therefore, if the UN does not assume a more active role in this critical issue, international peace and security will be under serious threat. Otherwise, Einstein’s pessimistic prediction risks becoming a reality.




