HomeExpertsConfronting the Web of Conspiracy Theories in Turkey

Confronting the Web of Conspiracy Theories in Turkey

One indicator of a person’s honesty and the logical consistency in their speech is whether they engage in fallacies, intentionally or unintentionally. Defined as baseless and unfounded speech, a fallacy is, in its simplest form, deceitful reasoning. Fallacies, or deceitful reasonings, often appear as seeing all means as permissible to convince the other person. At the forefront of those who use fallacies in this manner are undoubtedly conspiracy theorists in Turkey.

When specific events are attempted to be understood not through their process and context but via conspiracy theories, the overall perception of reality is lost, and what is presented becomes merely fallacious.

Some of the fallacies that conspiracists resort to include mistaking one of two consecutive events as the cause of the other, continuously reinterpreting historical events to establish new sequential relationships, believing events happening at the same time are causally related, shifting meanings by emphasizing a particular expression, distorting an event by using two different meanings of an expression, constantly changing claims as if always defending the latest version, confusing what is with what ought to be, diverting the topic to an unrelated area, establishing similarity or relationship between two unrelated things, and trying to make people accept a claim through fear.

We are hearing a new fallacy these days. The door picture in Fethullah Gülen’s newly published book “Surah Yusuf” and a phrase in the poem he read are connected to a decision made by the Council of State regarding judges, spawning conspiracy theories so bizarre that the situation has become clinical. For those who know the subject, the performance presented doesn’t even seem funny.

There’s a deep mindset problem! The situation has reached such an absurd point that people can now believe in conflicting conspiracy theories at the same time. Those who believe the community is being targeted from all sides also believe that members of the Hizmet Movement are planning a uprising. Those convinced there are no community members left in public service also believe there are many Hizmet Movement leaders in public administration. People who believe in the appointment of trustees to the Sızıntı magazine because ‘we have entered their dens’ can also believe in a connection between a poem by Necip Fazıl in an issue published during the trusteeship and a coup! However, believing in contradictory conspiracy theories at the same time is not commentary but a mindset problem stemming from a perspective on events.

In Turkey, the concerted effort of both the government and the opposition has turned conspiracy paranoia from an ideological stance or clinical condition into a lifestyle itself. Thanks to these efforts, it’s not hard to guess that we are among the world leaders in the prevalence of conspiracy mentality!

Here’s an example. In a 2020 study with 22,000 people across 21 countries, participants were asked about 8 different conspiracy theories. According to the study, Turks (55%) believed the most among 21 nations that America had a hand in the 9/11 attacks. They ranked second in believing that the AIDS virus was deliberately created (40%) and that the moon landing was fake (28%); third in believing that the side effects of vaccines are hidden (48%) and that humanity has secret contacts with aliens (41%); fourth in believing that the world is governed by secret groups (57%); and sixth in believing that Donald Trump collaborated with the Russians during his election campaign (56%).

The widespread belief in conspiracy theories is, as expected, due to distrust. Initially, conspiracy belief takes advantage of this climate of distrust to take root in minds, further damaging the already fragile sense of trust, with the government attempting to secure political legitimacy for the injustices, oppressions, and economic crises experienced.

The easiest way; find a scapegoat, declare them guilty! Economic crises, human rights violations, social unrest, and many such incidents can largely be attributed to conspiracy theorists. Normal people feel guilty and ashamed when things go wrong. Human psychology will either accept this discomfort and decide on a course of action accordingly or seek another guilty party to escape this feeling. This is where conspiracy theory comes into play. Because conspiracy theories provide psychological reasons that eliminate the feeling of guilt, sophists choose to shift responsibility to the enemy to escape. A scapegoat is found, and the easiest way to escape responsibility is discovered. Now, conspiracy theories can be listed in peace.

Besides being scientifically problematic, the promotion of discrimination, legitimization of hate crimes, use as a tool of exploitation, and spreading of distrust are undoubtedly harmful to society. The continuation of conspiracy theories in this environment is a reality. At this stage, what we can do to prevent harm to both our mental health and the society we live in is to laugh off the sophistry of the conspiracists.

Take a second to support Politurco.com on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!
NURULLAH ALBAYRAK
NURULLAH ALBAYRAK
Nurullah Albayrak is lawyer and columnist at TR724.com
RELATED ARTICLES
- Advertisment -spot_img

Most Popular

Recent Comments