For the past one or two centuries, Muslims seem to have lost their way and direction. There is still no consensus on a unified goal. Although no one is satisfied with the current situation, they do not fully understand what they need, how to escape the present crisis, or exactly what steps to take.
Today, there are numerous issues that need to be addressed and resolved in religious, moral, political, legal, economic, and social domains. The Islamic world has lost its political power and dominance over the past few centuries. Its unity has been shattered. Centuries-old institutions have been destroyed, yet no new ones have been established in their place. It has fallen far behind the West in science and technology. It has succumbed to poverty and deprivation. It has lost its moral strength, hope, and self-confidence. On one side, it has been subjected to the tyranny of oppressive rulers, and on the other, it has fallen under the hegemony of modernity.
It has failed to provide satisfactory responses to the challenges posed by modern Western values. It has been unable to demonstrate how Islam, with its unique values, can contribute to the happiness of contemporary humanity in both this world and the hereafter. In fact, it has failed to present a compelling example of how to remain Muslim in the modern world and how to integrate Islamic values into daily life.
For the past one or two centuries, Muslims have not been entirely passive in diagnosing the causes of this deep crisis and seeking solutions for liberation. They have been working and striving. This is why various thinkers and scholars have put forth reform demands and different theories of salvation.
Some revival movements have emerged in the Islamic world; various communities, institutions, or states have made efforts toward reform. Among these, some emphasized the importance of education and the need for reform in this area. Others focused on returning to the core principles of Islam (the Qur’an and Sunnah). Some argued for religious reform to achieve an Islamic enlightenment. Others blamed traditional interpretations and proposed alternative approaches such as historicism and hermeneutics to reinterpret religious texts.
Some believed that the core problem was the dominance of imitation in the Islamic world, and the solution was to reinvigorate the institution of independent reasoning (ijtihad). Even radical groups emerged, seeking to achieve their goals through violence and terrorism.
However, alongside all these efforts, much of the focus and ambition has been directed toward the struggle for power and political dominance. Steps have been taken to establish an Islamic state governed by Sharia law. Minds have been preoccupied with concepts such as caliphate, Sharia, sovereignty, governance, jihad, and the Islamic state, with discussions and debates revolving around these themes. The West has been held responsible for the backwardness of Muslims. Not only has Western colonialism, oppression, and interventions been blamed for underdevelopment, but also for many ongoing problems in the Islamic world.
Furthermore, the spread of ideologies such as democracy, secularism, and capitalism—imported from the West—was identified as the primary factor responsible for the decline of Islamic life. Consequently, the only necessary means to counter these influences was perceived as power and sovereignty.
Those who embrace these views are generally referred to as “Islamists” or advocates of “Political Islam.” In a previous article, we explored in detail what Political Islam is, how it emerged, what it aims for, and what state it is in today. We pointed out the aspects where it is both right and mistaken and provided an overall critique of Political Islam. Therefore, we will not repeat that discussion here. However, it should be noted that the views and approaches advocated by Islamists have been widely accepted among large segments of the Muslim population.
By examining the language, concepts, goals, and strategies used by Political Islamists, one can easily conclude that they have turned Islam into an ideology. While ideologies such as liberalism, socialism, capitalism, communism, modernism, postmodernism, and nationalism continue to dominate the modern world, Islamism has also positioned itself as an ideological movement among them. Like other ideologies, it aims for political revolution and the establishment of a new social order. By seizing power, it seeks to create an alternative system and reshape law, economy, politics, education, and culture according to its principles.
One could analyze the extent to which Political Islamists have succeeded and whether they have achieved their goals. However, what we want to highlight here is a different issue. Instead of living, representing, and sustaining Islam, they have turned it into an ideology. Moreover, they did not just ideologize Islam—they also secularized, instrumentalized, and politicized it.
While seeking to establish Islam’s dominance, they inadvertently subordinated it to their political ambitions and power struggles. They adopted a passionate, reactionary, emotional, aggressive, and defensive stance. More importantly, they disrupted the core structure of Islam, altered its priorities, and overlooked faith, morality, and religious practice. Since their energy and efforts were focused on the struggle for power and dominance, they failed to concentrate on the development of individuals. They could not cultivate faithful, moral, virtuous, and conscious individuals.
According to them, the source of existing oppression, injustices, exploitation, misery, and underdevelopment was external enemies. Therefore, without liberating themselves from the occupation and dominance of “infidels,” without achieving complete independence, and without gaining full sovereignty, it was impossible to practice true religiosity. Hence, individual spiritual development was set aside, religious practices were postponed, and all efforts were directed toward power and politics. It was as if once Muslim rulers took control of governments and states, all problems related to religion and religious life would automatically be solved.
Even worse, Islamists did not merely suspend morality and religious practices until they achieved their political goals—they also justified actions explicitly forbidden by Islam, such as lying, slander, deception, bribery, theft, corruption, favoritism, usurpation, and oppression. They acted with a Machiavellian mindset, legitimizing every means that served their ends—not in their words, but in their actions. By reinterpreting certain religious concepts and principles according to their own perspectives, they easily found justifications for their sins.
However, they were mistaken in one fundamental aspect: Real change must begin within the individual—within their heart, mind, emotions, and thoughts—before it can extend outward to life, society, and institutions. Only such a transformation can be permanent and promising for the future. But a top-down change imposed through pressure and despotism would provoke resistance and remain unsustainable.
Muslims have been exploited because—according to Malik Bennabi—they became “exploitable,” meaning they weakened in faith, became morally corrupt, and intellectually barren. Setting aside the oppression and crimes committed by Western states in recent centuries, we must acknowledge that Muslims’ long-standing negligence and faults have contributed to today’s situation. Therefore, before blaming others, we must engage in serious self-examination, invest in faith, morality, spirituality, knowledge, and education, and take the lead in cultivating upright believers.
It is evident that individuals who have not internalized the teachings of the Qur’an and Sunnah, and whose minds and hearts have not been illuminated by the light of revelation, will not become more moral and religious when they gain power. On the contrary, power will corrupt them further, and the privileges of authority will lead them into indulgence. In other words, they will neither be able to practice the religiosity they postponed, nor will they be able to maintain their existing moral standards.
Bediüzzaman Said Nursî’s observation is highly relevant here: “In Sharia, ninety-nine percent pertains to morality, worship, the afterlife, and virtue. Only one percent relates to politics.” Regardless of where a Muslim lives, unless faced with severe oppression, they can practice most of their religion. They recognize that the teachings and objectives of the Qur’an and Sunnah can be applied in every time and place and focus on these aspects. They cannot postpone their religious responsibilities by claiming that the current regime or system is not fully compatible with Islam. If they seek a transformation aligned with religious values, they understand that the path to this lies in educating individuals with faith and morality.




