HomeTop Stories On TurkeyErdogan’s Failed Crusade: Why the World’s Cold Feet on Hizmet Oppression?

Erdogan’s Failed Crusade: Why the World’s Cold Feet on Hizmet Oppression?

FELIX KAIZA

Reading between the lines of the just-released report by Solidarity With Others, my first article, to an extent, depicted the world’s sum total disbelief in the Turkish government’s efforts to categorize the Gulen Movement as terrorist. This second input throws further light on the issue and questions:

“If that is the case, what makes the world develop cold feet in taking Erdogan’s rule to task over the ongoing unjust political, social, and economic hardships inflicted on the Turkish people and vivid contradictions to global ethical behavior?”

Now we know for sure: the Gulen Movement, also known as Hizmet (Service), had no role to play in the contentious July 15, 2016, failed coup in Turkey. Whether that was a coup or a coup-that-was is not the issue of this article. Instead, this digs deeper into how Erdogan’s campaign has failed and why the world has continued to take a lukewarm position instead of nipping the government’s inhumane and undemocratic practices in the bud.

Based on various United Nations organizations’ reports concerning extensive human rights violations targeting the Gulen Movement and perceived members—particularly that of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR)—the UN Security Council threw Erdogan’s claims out the window. Likewise, the Council of Europe more than frowned at Turkey’s use of transnational repression tactics and seamless application of anti-terrorism laws impacting civil society and trampling on democratic and human rights obligations. The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) outrightly condemned Turkey’s misuse of counterterrorism measures to persecute individuals without substantive evidence—a stance that was equally adopted by the EU counterterrorism chief’s office. In fact, intelligence reports cleared the movement, suggesting instead that the Turkish government used its ‘home-baked’ coup to eliminate political rivals.

A quick country-by-country trek reveals:

  • United Kingdom – Foreign affairs and Commonwealth office corridors questioned Erdogan’s views on Gulen.
  • Germany – Visualizes Hizmet as a civilian association for religious and secular education.
  • Canada – Despite being pressured by Turkey to extradite alleged Gulenists, it notes that individual victims are often identified based on perceived affiliations rather than concrete evidence.

This view is shared by other countries and organizations, including the Council of Europe’s Venice Commission and the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention. Credible human rights organizations such as Human Rights Watch (HRW), Amnesty International, and Freedom House have condemned Turkey for systematic human rights abuses.

From human rights and legal perspectives, respective organizations have criticized Turkey’s broad and vague anti-terrorism measures targeting the Gülen Movement, involving persecution through arbitrary detention, torture, and extraterritorial killings.

The Unanswered Question

If world governments and organizations in the north and south, east and west, and even in Turkey itself are certain about the Turkish government’s mistreatment of innocent people, why has there been no action taken?

  • Why have the people of Turkey been abandoned?
  • Why have their rights been ignored?

This raises the pertinent issue of respect, which is the foundation of humane and ethical behavior. It involves a fundamental belief in people’s right to exist, be heard, and enjoy equal opportunities in society.

Those who have studied Latin will most probably remember that, irrespective of Anglo (English) Middle Ages and French claims, respect finds its root in the Latin noun respectus, meaning regard, derived from the verb respicere, meaning to look back. In a way, therefore, it can be taken as a desirable attitude—something important in life, particularly when it touches others. It is a universal honor, apt for all people, and yields good results in social, economic, and political relationships. It is a source of peace. It is a right and very inalienable. It is power. It is an insurance against, and a cure for, situations like conflict and violence.

Some literature considers protecting human rights essential for seven reasons:

  1. Dignity and Respect
  2. Justice and Equality
  3. Peace and Stability
  4. Empowerment
  5. Development and Prosperity
  6. Global Responsibility
  7. Moral Obligation

This reminded me of the famous Seven Wonders of the World, only that these could be called the Seven Wonders of Good Governance. Conversely, one could also recall the famous Indian leader Mahatma Gandhi’s Seven Blunders of the World, including “Politics without Principles”, which, in this respect, fits the Turkish government squarely—as evidenced by the Solidarity With Others report on “The Gülen Movement: Challenging Turkey’s ‘Terrorist Organization’ Narrative Through Global Perspectives.”

The Erdogan Dilemma

Dealing with Erdogan, however, is no easy task—but not impossible either. He is more than a double dealer—call him “multiple,” if it pleases you.

  • The Turkish government is a friend of the United States and its Western allies in NATO.
  • A leading and prominent country in the Muslim and Arab world, Turkey was one of the first to recognize Israel.
  • As a NATO member, Turkey has military bases protecting Israel.
  • When Erdogan came to power, he promised to protect Israel under any circumstances.
  • For a long time, Turkey has been a training ground for Israeli air pilots.
  • Turkey exports whatever Israel needs.
  • At the same time, Turkey supports Hamas’ cause in Palestine.
  • Similarly, Turkey is a mirror of Russia and its Eastern allies regarding NATO and remains a strategic business partner.

When COVID-19 was at its peak, prompting the UN to plead with member countries to reduce prison populations, Erdogan jumped on the wagon—but in a way that discriminated against Gulen Movement inmates.

What Now?

All said, it is not enough for the world to condemn the Erdogan government, sit back, and wait for positive results. Protecting human rights is a practical affair and a shared responsibility.

Violations in Turkey have global repercussions, affecting international relations, trade, and security. Therefore, the protection of human rights is not just a national issue, but a global moral obligation.

The truth remains:

To foster a just, equitable, and peaceful Turkish society, upholding human rights is vital for global stability and development. There is no alternative. And no country is an exception.

All stakeholders must come forward and participate in this shared commitment to human rights and justice.

Indeed, Erdogan’s efforts to pull the world’s leg on the designation of the Gulen Movement have failed. But the persecution of its members continues.

Dignity, respect, equality, and justice must be restored in Turkey for peace and development.

Take a second to support Politurco.com on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!
Politurco
Politurco
Politurco.com is a new online platform which primarily focuses on Turkish politics, Middle East and Muslim world with a high commitment to standards of journalistic and academic ethics and integrity.
RELATED ARTICLES
- Advertisment -spot_img

Most Popular

Recent Comments