HomeHeadlineHashim Thaçi, Accused of Handing Gülen-Affiliated Educators to Turkey, Sentenced to 25...

Hashim Thaçi, Accused of Handing Gülen-Affiliated Educators to Turkey, Sentenced to 25 Years

The former Kosovo president was convicted in The Hague of war crimes committed during the 1998–1999 conflict. His downfall has also revived memories of the unlawful 2018 rendition of six Turkish nationals—five educators and a doctor—to Erdoğan’s government.

Former Kosovo President Hashim Thaçi has been sentenced to 25 years in prison after being convicted of war crimes by the Kosovo Specialist Chambers in The Hague.

Thaçi, 58, was found guilty of murder, torture, cruel treatment and unlawful detention committed during the 1998–1999 Kosovo war, when he was a senior commander of the Kosovo Liberation Army, commonly known as the KLA.

According to the judgment, Thaçi bore criminal responsibility for the deaths of 96 people, many of whom were perceived political opponents or individuals suspected of collaborating with Serbian forces. The court also held him responsible for the unlawful detention of 385 people, the torture of 303 detainees and the cruel treatment of dozens of others.

The prosecution had requested a 45-year sentence. Thaçi, who denied all the charges throughout the proceedings, is expected to appeal the verdict. The court acquitted him and his co-defendants of crimes against humanity after finding insufficient evidence that the attacks were sufficiently widespread or systematic.

The ruling represents a dramatic fall for a man who was once regarded as one of the central figures in Kosovo’s struggle for independence and its subsequent state-building process.

From KLA commander to president—and then The Hague

Thaçi was one of the most prominent political leaders to emerge from the KLA. After the war, he became prime minister and later president of Kosovo, cultivating close relations with Western governments and presenting himself as a symbol of the country’s independence.

However, allegations concerning the conduct of senior KLA commanders continued to follow him. The Kosovo Specialist Chambers—established under Kosovo law but based in The Hague because of concerns over witness intimidation—eventually indicted Thaçi and three other former KLA leaders: Kadri Veseli, Rexhep Selimi and Jakup Krasniqi.

After the indictment against him was confirmed in 2020, Thaçi resigned from the presidency and was transferred to The Hague. His trial began in 2023 and included testimony from more than 130 witnesses.

The September 16 verdict confirmed that political stature, revolutionary credentials and international recognition do not place former leaders beyond the reach of criminal accountability.

The 2018 rendition of Turkish educators

For members of Turkey’s persecuted Gülen movement, however, Thaçi’s name carries another troubling association.

On March 29, 2018, Kosovo authorities detained six Turkish citizens—five educators and one doctor—and rapidly transferred them to Turkey. The men were accused by Ankara of having links to the Gülen movement, which President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s government blames for the failed coup attempt of July 2016.

The detainees were not given a meaningful opportunity to challenge their removal. They were denied normal access to lawyers and were placed on a Turkish aircraft before their families and much of Kosovo’s political leadership understood what was happening.

The operation was widely described by human rights organizations as an unlawful rendition conducted through cooperation between Kosovo’s intelligence service and Turkey’s National Intelligence Organization, or MİT. Civil Rights Defenders said the six men had been arbitrarily arrested and denied the right to a fair legal process.

Then-Prime Minister Ramush Haradinaj said that he had not been informed of the operation in advance. He subsequently dismissed Kosovo’s interior minister and the head of the Kosovo Intelligence Agency. The European Union also criticized the deportations, saying that the operation raised serious questions about Kosovo’s and Turkey’s respect for human rights and the rule of law.

A parliamentary investigation later identified numerous violations of Kosovo’s Constitution, domestic law and international conventions. The commission’s report placed political responsibility on Thaçi, although he denied ordering or directing the operation.

It is important to distinguish the two cases: Thaçi’s 25-year sentence concerns crimes committed during the Kosovo war, not the 2018 rendition of the Turkish nationals. Nevertheless, the deportation episode remains an important part of his political record.

Erdoğan publicly thanked Kosovo’s operation

The rendition was part of a broader international campaign carried out by the Erdoğan government against Gülen movement members living abroad. Turkish intelligence conducted or facilitated similar operations in several countries, often targeting teachers, school administrators and businesspeople who had sought protection outside Turkey.

Following the Kosovo operation, Erdoğan openly praised those involved and sharply criticized Haradinaj for dismissing the officials responsible. His reaction reinforced suspicions that the operation had been coordinated at the highest political levels.

For Ankara, it was presented as a successful counterterrorism mission. For human rights advocates, it was an example of transnational repression: the use of intelligence cooperation, diplomatic pressure and irregular deportation procedures to seize government critics beyond Turkey’s borders.

Kosovo, a young republic founded on demands for freedom and protection from state persecution, had surrendered six legal residents to a government known for mass arrests, politically motivated prosecutions and serious allegations of mistreatment in custody.

A wider lesson in accountability

Thaçi remains a national hero to many Kosovars, who view the KLA as the force that liberated the country from Serbian repression. His conviction has therefore generated anger and protests among supporters who believe the tribunal has unfairly targeted Kosovo’s wartime leadership.

Yet recognizing the Serbian forces’ extensive crimes against Kosovo Albanians does not require ignoring crimes committed by KLA members. A liberation movement’s cause cannot serve as permanent immunity for murder, torture or unlawful detention.

The same principle applies to the six Turkish nationals handed over in 2018. Governments cannot invoke national security or counterterrorism as a substitute for evidence, judicial review and due process. Nor can political leaders escape responsibility indefinitely by allowing intelligence agencies and subordinate officials to carry out operations while publicly claiming ignorance.

Thaçi’s conviction does not legally resolve the unanswered questions surrounding the rendition of the Gülen-affiliated educators. It does, however, carry a broader message: power may postpone accountability, but it does not always erase it.

The former president who once stood at the center of Kosovo’s liberation narrative will now spend decades in prison. For the families of those unlawfully seized and delivered to Erdoğan’s government, the verdict may also revive a question that Kosovo has never fully answered: Who authorized the operation of March 29, 2018—and why has no senior political figure been held accountable for it?

Take a second to support Politurco.com on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!
Politurco
Politurco
Politurco.com is a new online platform which primarily focuses on Turkish politics, Middle East and Muslim world with a high commitment to standards of journalistic and academic ethics and integrity.
RELATED ARTICLES
- Advertisment -spot_img

Most Popular

Recent Comments