“You don’t need to kill a person to destroy them; stripping them of their humanity is enough.” – Hannah Arendt
The political rhetoric that begins with “eradication” first dehumanizes the opponent, then criminalizes them—feeding dictatorship, not democracy. Breaking this dangerous cycle, which continues until the last dissenter is silenced, is essential for the survival of democracy.
Literal Meaning First
The phrase “telef etmek” in Turkish refers to the killing of animals. According to the Turkish Language Association, the word “telef” is of Arabic origin, meaning annihilation, death, destruction, or killing. “Telef etmek” means to kill or destroy an animal.
When used for humans, this term becomes a metaphor that serves to dehumanize the target and reduce them to the level of animals. To associate a political rival with the verb “telef olmak” (to be eradicated) linguistically reflects the effort to depict them not as human, but as something akin to an animal.
In political discourse, using expressions like “telef etmek” or “telef olmak” doesn’t just imply defeating a political opponent—it implies their complete erasure, as if removing a carcass from the political arena. No great intellect is needed to grasp this.
At its most charitable interpretation, such language indicates a departure from the principle of mutual respect fundamental to democratic politics. It reduces politics to a mere struggle for survival. Labeling a political rival as “telef” strips them of legitimacy and casts them as a harmful element that must be destroyed.
A Historical Pattern
Throughout history, eliminating political rivals has been one of the darkest features of politics.
From the Roman Empire to modern totalitarian regimes, the physical, political, or social elimination of rivals has been a common strategy to maintain power. In ancient Rome, eliminating rivals was almost a ritual upon an emperor’s ascension. Even the Ottoman Empire institutionalized this through the legal practice of fratricide.
In the modern era, Stalin’s “Great Purge,” where opponents were labeled “enemies of the people,” was one of the most systematic examples. Under Hitler, opponents were first smeared, then imprisoned, and often murdered. In Latin America, the phenomenon of “disappeared” dissidents represents a more covert form of physical elimination.
Today, physical elimination has largely been replaced by political and social purging. Tactics now include discrediting rivals through media smear campaigns, banning them from politics using the judiciary, imprisoning them, or cutting off their financial resources. These modern methods of “eradication” don’t require physical violence but still aim to end the target’s political existence.
When rulers use terms like “telef olmak,” it’s a clear signal of their intent to dehumanize and devalue their rivals. This language erodes the culture of dialogue and respect required by democracy and instead turns politics into a battle for survival.
Dehumanization: A Precursor to Atrocity
Dehumanization is the process of stripping individuals or groups of their human identity and value, portraying them as inferior beings. This has historically played a key role in justifying oppression.
There are several types:
- Verbal dehumanization: Using animalistic labels like “cockroach,” “rat,” “pig,” or applying animal-related verbs like “telef olmak” to humans.
- Mechanization: Defining people as machines, robots, or numbers, thereby erasing their individuality. The most shocking example is how concentration camp prisoners were referred to by numbers.
- Biological metaphors: Referring to people as “virus,” “disease,” or “cancer,” suggesting they must be cleansed from society. Remember Vural Savaş, the notorious 28 February prosecutor in Turkey, who called members of a political party “blood-sucking bats” and “malignant tumors.” These terms were later even used as book titles by pro-military journalists.
- Moral exclusion: Pushing certain groups outside the boundaries of moral concern, making any harm done to them exempt from ethical scrutiny.
Dehumanization has almost always preceded genocides, mass violence, and systemic discrimination. During the Rwandan Genocide, Tutsis were called “cockroaches.” In Nazi Germany, Jews were described as “lice” and “rats.” Colonial regimes labeled indigenous people as “savages” and “primitive.”
Today, as exemplified by Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, dehumanization is often carried out in more subtle but equally dangerous ways. Erdoğan has used a rich array of terms: “drunkards,” “looters,” “whores,” “spawn of Jews/Armenians,” “salivating,” “leeches,” “scum.”
The danger of dehumanization lies in its ability to normalize violence and rights violations against the target group—even portraying such actions as moral duties.
Next Step: Criminalization
Criminalization follows dehumanization. It uses legal frameworks to neutralize political opponents.
Key elements of this strategy include:
- Lawmaking: Enacting new laws that criminalize dissent under terms like “counterterrorism,” “national security,” or “public order.”
- Expanding interpretation of existing laws: Vague laws are broadly interpreted to target dissent, such as accusations of “insulting state institutions” or “disturbing public order.”
- Selective justice: Laws are not applied equally. Critics are punished, but similar acts by pro-government figures are ignored.
- Politicizing the judiciary: Weakening the independence of judges and prosecutors to control politically sensitive trials.
Historical examples are plentiful. In the Soviet Union, dissenters were tried for “anti-Soviet propaganda.” In Latin America, critics were accused of “subversive activities.” Today, activists in some countries are prosecuted for “collaborating with foreign powers.”
This strategy differs from physical elimination in that it maintains the façade of a rule-of-law state. It allows the regime to claim that it’s acting legally, even while suppressing dissent. This legal cover also serves as a shield against international criticism. For instance, after revoking press credentials and jailing opposition journalists, Erdoğan claimed: “There are no journalists in prison—they are criminals!”
The Opposition’s Blind Spot
The saddest part is this: when the opposition is unaware of or even adopts the regime’s narrative, the situation becomes dire—as is currently happening in Turkey.
So how long will this go on? We return to the beginning: this poisonous cycle will continue until the last dissenter is eradicated.
Unfortunately, it’s clear that Turkey’s political opposition—especially Özgür Özel—is not capable of understanding this dynamic.




