Necip F. Bahadır
In recent years, Turkey has become a textbook example of how democratic institutions can erode under one-man rule. What makes this trajectory even more striking is that some of the sharpest criticisms are now coming from people who once helped build the very political movement that now presides over Turkey’s decline.
One such voice is Hüseyin Çelik, a founding member of Turkey’s ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) and a former education minister under President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Once at the center of Turkish politics, Çelik now joins a small but growing number of former insiders willing to publicly challenge Erdoğan’s increasingly autocratic rule — even as the risks for dissent grow daily in Turkey.
Earlier this year, Çelik joined a group of nineteen prominent Turkish conservatives who published a declaration bluntly titled the “Declaration of Justice.” Its core message is both simple and damning: “The rule of law no longer exists in Turkey.” For those observing Turkey from abroad, this is not a new accusation. But coming from founding members of the party that swept to power promising to reform Turkish democracy, it carries a different weight.
From Reform to Authoritarianism
When the AKP was founded in 2001, many believed it would reconcile Islamic values with democratic governance, offering Turkey a middle path distinct from both military secularism and Islamist authoritarianism. The party attracted figures like Hüseyin Çelik, who entered politics from Turkey’s center-right tradition and hoped the AKP would offer a modern, inclusive vision for the country.
In its early years, the AKP did in fact pursue reforms that brought Turkey closer to European standards, strengthened the economy, and challenged the military’s historical dominance over civilian politics. But over time, power became increasingly concentrated in Erdoğan’s hands. Critics were marginalized. Independent voices — both within the party and in society — were silenced. Today, few of Erdoğan’s original allies remain at his side. Figures such as former President Abdullah Gül and former parliamentary speaker Bülent Arınç have quietly withdrawn from public life, while others, like Çelik, have finally begun speaking out.
Erdoğan’s Turkey has not simply drifted into authoritarianism; it has undergone a systematic dismantling of democratic norms. As Hüseyin Çelik put it in a recent interview:
“If a republic is not democratic, it is worthless. At that point, whether you call it a republic or a monarchy makes no difference.”
He goes further, drawing a direct comparison that many Turks now whisper privately:
“Today, there is no real difference between Turkey’s Parliament and Putin’s Duma in Russia. Never in Turkey’s history has Parliament been this powerless.”

A Country in Crisis
Turkey’s democratic backsliding has not occurred in a vacuum. The country is also grappling with severe economic distress. Inflation remains cripplingly high, wages have stagnated, and unemployment — particularly among Turkey’s youth — is surging. Millions struggle to meet basic needs. As Çelik bluntly states, “Everyone knows how bad the economy is. People are barely surviving.”
In such a climate, citizens are not only hungry for economic relief but for something even more elusive under Erdoğan’s rule: justice, accountability, and freedom of expression. Yet speaking out in Turkey remains dangerous. Laws are weaponized against political opponents; the judiciary is largely subservient to the executive; and journalists, academics, and activists routinely face prosecution.
Even Turkey’s universities have not been spared. Çelik expressed particular outrage at the political targeting of Istanbul’s popular opposition mayor, Ekrem İmamoğlu, whose university diploma was recently annulled under dubious legal pretexts:
“If a country’s universities have reached this point, it is a disgrace. I am both a graduate and a former faculty member of Istanbul University. This decision is shameful.”
The Cost of Silence
Hüseyin Çelik’s willingness to speak up, while still rare, reflects a growing unease even among some of Erdoğan’s former supporters. But the silence of others — including figures like Abdullah Gül and Bülent Arınç — remains deafening. As Çelik himself warns, history will not be kind to those who failed to raise their voices in these dark hours.
Turkey was once seen as a model for blending Islam, democracy, and economic modernization in the Muslim world. Today, it more closely resembles the autocracies it once sought to distinguish itself from. As Çelik and others have made clear, this is not the country they sought to build. And unless more voices from within Turkey’s own political establishment break their silence, Erdoğan’s grip on power may only tighten further — pushing Turkey even deeper into authoritarianism.




